The only way to actually surpass the visual novel is to make an aanime that can last for more than 80 episodes, and is able to put EVERY SINGLE dialogue that was shown in the game.
NEVER(Unless the VN is a total piece of shit, and the anime revised almost all scenes because of its shitiness) I could care less who or what company makes the LB anime, all I care about is that they make a good job doing it.Ĥ.) There is no existing anime that has EVER surpassed their Visual Novel counterparts. For me, the reason why I'm complaining is because KyoAni would have made a better job since their more experienced in making Key's visual novels. NOTE: I'm not saying J.C Staff is worse than KyoAni, and please don't group me with the KyoAni groupies that are complaining simply because LB will be made by J.C Rather than KyoAni. I have no idea what happened to Kappei, but I can guess that they didn't include him since that would mess up future episodes for Kyou). (Kyou and Tomoyo are summarized in 1 episode, which is what I consider to be very stupid since each route from the original VN took me more than 23 hours each. KyoAni never rushed on the routes, but they DID do something worse, which was completely ignore 3 routes namely Kyou, Tomoyo and Kappei routes. The anime CANNOT summarize a 100+ hour gameplay in 26 Season1+26 second season (if there IS a second season which would most probably be refrain) episodes cannot contain 100+ hours of gameplay.Ģ.) J.C Staff has enhanced the comedy of the anime, much like how KyoAni was able to make the Clannad anime funnier than the actual Visual Novel, HOWEVER, unlike KyoAni, J.C Staff added a few unnecessary scenes in some of the episodes, whereas KyoAni never added original content into Clannad other than combining Tomoyo route and Kyou route, then making them heartbroken at the end is purely Original from KyoAni (comment on that if I'm wrong).ģ.) Unlike KyoAni, J.C Staff rushed the routes of the girls into 1 season (please note that I am 100% sure that they will finish all routes by the end of the first season, if there will be second season, its definitely only for refrain). If you don't skip, it'll take you 230+ hours) To summarize everything that I know.ġ.) The visual Novel is considered an epic Visual Novel with 100 hours + gameplay WHERE EVERY LINE OF DIALOGUE COUNTS TO THE EPICNESS OF THE VN (if you choose to skip the common route it'll be 80+ hours, to be safe, I'll make it 100+ hours. Tl dr play the VN and (if you like it) watch the anime after for some nostalgia - unless you get too irritated with severe pacing problems and lack of romance in some routes. Can't say more because of spoilers, but when you finish the VN you'll understand what it is.
That's why I think VN fans has most chance of liking them (since they already know the original story).Īlso, there's a "storytelling trick" that the anime can't reproduce entirely, no matter how good that adaptation could be.
The girls routes until now range from average (Komari) to good (Mio), they are the best adapted parts homever, when the whole content doesn't make the audience feel for the characters, they are kinda ineffective. The common route adaptation is the main source of the problem: introductions of characters and comedy scenes are way too stretched, taking time that could be used to character development one route was inserted before the end of the introductions also, Rin's development feel inconsistent. Surely it is faithful to the main events of the story and is telling it in a new perspective, but some strong pacing issues can ruin the experience for most anime-only viewers. Let's say that I disagree that the anime is a good adaptation. At this point, I just see the anime as some enjoyment for those who played the VN and want to see some scenes animated (even though JC animation is really average). As I've already downloaded it, I need to know if it's as good or better than the for the moment ongoing anime?
0 kommentar(er)
